The Sound of Silence: Analysis

And the people bowed and prayed
To the neon god they made …

SAMSUNG DIGITAL CAMERA

 

The oxymoron  (=combination of words having opposite or very different meanings) in the title gives a good idea of incommunicability among people
The poem ‘The Sound of Silence’ consists of five irregular stanzas in which the poet describes  the conflict between spiritual and material values in our  modern world.

Hello darkness, my old friend
I’ve come to talk with you again
Because a vision softly creeping
Left its seeds while I was sleeping
And the vision that was planted in my brain
Still remains
Within the sound of silence

The poem begins with an address to darkness. The narrator says that he has come to talk to it  because a certain vision has  planted its seeds in his brain while he was sleeping. The vision still remains there in  the sound of silence.

The singer seems to realise  what we are in essence – lonely people,  living in the darkness, in  the  void. Maybe we  are aware we are  familiar with the darkness , but he has had a  “vision softly creeping” , a sort of inspiring dream  that has triggered a sort of self-awareness, of    enlightenment

In restless dreams I walked alone
Narrow streets of cobblestone
‘Neath the halo of a streetlamp
I turned my collar to the cold and damp
When my eyes were stabbed by the flash of a neon light
That split the night
And touched the sound of silence

Now the poet describes his restless dream, in which he seems alone, walking in a dark  world of nothingness. This might mean that the more enlightened we are , the lonelier  we become.  It is dark, cold and wet, and he  “Turned my collar to the cold and damp” to   highlight that we everybody seems obliged  to accept  bad conditions. Suddenly the  “neon light” hit his eyes, i.e. something arrived  to distract him  (he is still alone)  from his lonely feelings. . This refers to  the deceitful nature of life that  may prevent us  from realising the  emptiness or alienation of  our lives.
And in the naked light I saw
Ten thousand people, maybe more
People talking without speaking
People hearing without listening
People writing songs that voices never share
No one dare
Disturb the sound of silence
Now the sharp light allows him to see a lot people are talking without speaking and hearing without listening.  Some of them are even writing songs that will  never be sung.
Our meaningless existence  applies to everyone else, we fail to communicate, to enter into relationships with others.
The complete impersonality of a crowd is portrayed : not only are we lonely when we are alone, but we are also alone even when we are surrounded by other people.

Unfortunately, many of us  don’t really  pay attention to the content of what we  hear or  say. It is an image painted in the 1960s but it  anticipates  what is happening in our present society: people  next to each other seem to say things (on the phone or the social media)   to everybody  except the ones  immediately surrounding them.

Fools” said I, “You do not know
Silence like a cancer grows
Hear my words that I might teach you
Take my arms that I might reach you”
But my words like silent raindrops fell
And echoed in the wells of silence

The narrator  calls  them  fool, because  silence has an abnormal unhealthy growth, like   cancer. He asks them to hear his words and to hold his hand. He tries to warn the people in his dream, he invites them we try to rebel against the system, but they just turn their heads and look the other way.  It’s just easier to swim with the tide than against it.

And the people bowed and prayed
To the neon god they made
And the sign flashed out its warning
In the words that it was forming
And the sign said “The words of the prophets
Are written on the subway walls
And tenement halls
And whispered in the sounds of silence”

All those people don’t want to listen to his warnings,  are not  touched by his  his words . They  are giving all their attention to  the neon God they created and are  worshipping  all what it says  without using a voice.

When they are without religion, people try to find a meaning to life elsewhere, they may look for it in their belongings, without realizing   they want to find   meaning when there  is none.
The last phrase is strange  and it may  suggest that only when people are not completely conditioned, maybe in the poorest environments, there may be able to understand the revelation of the approaching doom

 

173 thoughts on “The Sound of Silence: Analysis

  1. Dear Luisa, your post is giving so much depth and insight to this poem / song. I listened now again and as always, it brings tears to my eyes as the words and music reach the heart. Simon & Garfunkel sings it with such gentleness and sadness.
    I thank you for sharing your deep and wonderful thoughts. 🙂

    miriam

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Yes… I’m sorry while I appreciate this view and interpretation of it as a person who has lived this and who lives this now I know and live the meaning of this song!! Even now!!!

    Society esp now…in this highly tech word we live in where everyone is living on their phones and TV’s and computers and in a massive world of non stop noise and crap and evil etc…. Where u r deep in a sea of people yet alone!!

    I am a musician and artist so I have this deep creative philosophical brain and mind!! I don’t think like the average Bear! I have always 🤔 outside the box!!! Always been hated for it to!! Even now I am strongly hated for the absolute truths I see on a deep deep level!!!

    Neon sign in today’s world means all the tech shit and how absorbed and wrapped up people r in it!! Not seeing anything but that!! It also means things like okay? When ur walking dn any busy town u see all these neon signs drawing ur attn to BARS! PORN PLACES!? STORES TECH And on and on an on!! I mean u drown in the sea of all the neon lights drawing ur attn away from u and people and who u r and who they r and the real meaning of life!!!

    Drawing u to the greed the drinking the drugs the violence!!! Killing stealing murder rape…. U name it!!

    Like rt now for instance where I am stuck living!? In this park from hell!! I live totally alone! In a sea of evilness where no one around me sees what’s real!!! No one here sees the TRUTH!!! LIKE REAL LIFE TRUTH!!! THEEE TRUTH!!! Here that truth is LYING CHEATING STEALING DRUG LORDS DRUG SELLERS DRUG USERS DRUNKS LYING GOSSIPS HIDING BEHIND THEIR CURTAINS AND DOORS LOOKING FOR ANYTHING OUTSIDE ON THEIR NEIGHBORS TO BEGIN THE NEXT JUICY GOSSIP! VIOLENCE!!! DEATH!!! FIGHTING KILLING BEATING ABUSE RAPE CHILD ABUSE ELDER ABUSE….SEVERE!!!….ANIMAL ABUSE AND TORTURE!!! AND THE TRUMP BS OF KKK SSNN PATRIOTS CLAIMING TO BE PATRIOTIC WHILE HATING U FOR BEING BLACK MEXICAN JEWISH DIFFERENT HANDICAPPED DISABLED FAT UGLY DISEASED POOR FIXED INCOME OR FOR JUST BEING HERE OR THERE!! OR FOR JUAT SIMPLY SPEAKING UR MIND AND SAYING WHAT U THINK OR BELIEVE!!!

    HERE!! WHERE I AM! THEY ALLLL DO THIS BELIEVE THIS BEHAVE THIS WAY!!! HERE 7 R MURDERED FOR SPEAKING TRUTH!! FOR SPEAKING THE TRUTH OF THIS I SAY RT HERE!!! FOR SPEAKING AGAINST DRUGS BOOZE RAISING HELL RAPING KILLING ABUSE CRIME AND THE REALITY OF THE LACK OF MORALS ETHICS HONOR AND TRUTH HERE!!!

    HERE NO ONE WANTS TO HEAR THE TRUTH!!!! IF U DARE SPEAK IT U FACE BEING TORTURED AND KILLED!!!

    The couple behind me fights often cursing each other slamming doors cheating on each other! They drink whore around steal use others and each other and commit crimes!

    In front of me is a large middle age woman who has been with several Charlie Mansions and made psychotic children with them! They moved in and the crime against each other and even me began!! They tried to kill each other!! Fought in rage non stop! Psycho boy got a riffle toted it around flaunting it…and as always his mother let him commit crimes encouraged him…sits at the table and does drugs with her kids which r like mentally retarded badly plus psycho because of all the drugs she did! They r truly ignorant violent like no conscience! Young Charlie Mansions only worse because they have NO INTELLGENCE AT ALL!!!

    He attacked me broke my windows out of my truck! My window sets cracked even now! He only left and the silence only returned in front of me when he took that gun and intended to blow his sorry sick mother’s brains out!! But he is dn the Rd somewhere with his dad! A sick CM kinda guy who rapes molest tortures abuses etc…. They beat and control and kill their women and find great pleasure in it!! It’s that way here!!

    These things r seen as normal here!! Folks either do it or keep their mouth shut!!! Their doors shut!!! Their curtains shut!!! If they r looking out for juicy gossip and see they pretend they saw nothing!! If they see anyone being hurt or killed or any animal they either d nothing behind closed doors or they get off standing and watching!!! Either way they do NOTHING!!!!

    THISSSSS IS WHAT THE SONG IS ABOUT!!!! SEEING THIS KINDA TRUTH!!?? AND EITHER DOING NOTHING!? STAYING SILENT!!!! OR SEEING IT AND KNOWING IT AND STILL REMAINING SILENT!! NEVER SPEAKING AGAINST THESE THINGS AND THESE KINDS OF PEOPLE OR ACTIONS BY THEM!!

    STANDING BY SILENT WHILE VIOLENCE AND ABUSE AND CRIME GOES UNCHECKED!!! DOING NOTHING TO TAKE A STAND OR TO CHANGE THINGS!!!

    IT SPEAKS OF THE VIET NAM WAR! OF RACISM!! OF HATE!! OF ABUSE! CRIME! MURDER! DYING! OF ESCAPING FROM REALITY BUT AT THE COST OF OUR OWN SOULS OUR OWN HUMANITY!!!

    It SPEAKS of living in an entire planet of people yet being totally alone!!!! While no one notices!!! While no one cares!!! There is an old man sitting alone in a motel rt now!! He is alone!!! He is naked!! In a wheel chair! His room is filthy! His bed and pillows r BLACK!!! His bed unmade with no sheets no covers of any kind!!! Bags of food thrown all over the floor!! Human piss on the floor!! He’s had no bath in ages!!! He reaks!!! He’s dying alone in absolute disgusting filth of unspeakable kind!!!! I have pics!!! Email me and I will gladly fwd them!!!! Or message me!? His name is George! The Cops know!! And do NOTHING!!! DHS KNOWS AND DOES NOTHING!!! THE ER KNOWS AND DOES NOTHING!!! HH KNOWS AND DOES NOTHING!

    I TRIED HARD TO!!! BUT GOT NOTHING BUT GRIEF AND HATE FOR IT!!

    WTH KIND OF SOCIETY DO WE LIVE IN WHERE OLD PEOPLE AND DISABLED PEOPLE AND DAVs LIVE THIS WAY AND DIE THIS WAY ALONE!!!!!???? WITH ABSOLUTELY NONE OF ANYONE CARING!!!!! NO ONE CARING OR GIVINF A SHIT!!!! NO ONE THINKING THIS IS WRONG OR EVIL OR IMMORAL OR UNETHICAL OR DISHONORABLE!!!!

    THISSSSS IS OUR THINKING NOW! THISSSSS IS OUR SOCIETY NOW!!! ESP POST COVID!!!! AND IT IS GETTING WORSE!!!! THIS WILL BE ALL OF US SOON…..!!?? CROWED IN A SEA OF SELFISHNESS GREED VIOLENCE SIN SOULLESSNESS!!!! WTH HAS FN HAPPENED TO HUMANS TO MANKIND!!!!????

    AND THIS IS WHAT THIS SONG SPEAKS OF!!!!!! THISSS IS WHAT HE THEY R SAYING!!! THEY R SAYING THAT THIS KIND OF SILENCE GROWS AND KILLS JUST LIKE CANCER!!!!! JUST LIK3 CANCER IT EATS AWAY AT UR SOUL AT WHO U R WHO WE R AS HUMANS AS SOCIETY!!!!

    AND THAT IF WE DO NOT BREAK THIS ROTTING INHUMANE SILENCE!!!! WE WILL ALL EITHER BE THIS OR BE SILENT VICTIMS OF THIS!!!! AND EACH OF US WILL DIE AN AWFUL DEATH ALONE IN A SEA OF ONLOOKERS WHO DO ABSOLUTELY NOTHING AND DO NOT CARE!!!! IN A SEA OF PEOPLE WHO ACCEPT THIS AS JUST THE WAY THINGS R!!!! INSTEAD OF SAYING HELL NO!!!!

    THIS IS NOT ME!!! AND I WONT LET IT BE ME!!! US!!!! HELL NO I WONT SET SILENT WHILE TH3SE THINGS HAPPEN RT IN FRONT OF ME!!!! WHILE HITLER ANILATES THE JEWS!!! WHILE ORANGE HITLER TRUMP OVERTHROWS OUR NATION AND PITS HIS SSNN KKK HATERS AGAINST THE REST OF US! WHILE HE DESTROYS SOCIETY!! WHILE HE PREACHES HATE!!! WHILE HE PREACHES AND ADVOCATES VIOLENCE!!! WHILE HE PREACHES HATE AGAINST ANYONE NOT WHITE OR RICH!!! WHILE HE REFUSED TO HELP THE POOR THE BLACKS THE MEXICANS THE DISABLED THE VETS THE ELDERLY!!!

    I MEAN WE TRULY HAD HAVE HITLER RT HERE IN OUR MIDST!! AND LIKE HITLER HE INTENDED AND STILL DOES TO TAKE OVER AND RULE AMERICA JUST LIKE HITLER RULED GERMANY!! AND FOLKS LIKE BLACKS MEXICANS OR DISABLED AND OLDER AND POOR LIKE ME OR THE TRUTH SEEKERS AND SPEAKERS LIKE ME BECOME THE IMPRISONED JEWS!!! WHILE QE R IMPRISONED AND ANILATED!!

    HATE THRIVES WHEN GOOD MEN WOMEN DO NOTHING!!!! HATE AND PREDJUDICED….LIKE A CANCER GROWS WHEN WE STAY SILENT AND WHEN WE TURN A BLIND EYE!!! WHEN WE SAY NOTHING!!! REPORT NOTHING! HELP NO ONE!!! SAVE NO ONE!

    WHEN WE LIVE ISOLATED IN FEAR!

    SOOOO I’m sorry!!! But while I respect ur views and thoughts here I strongly feel that the words here did NOTHING to truly describe WHAT… THE SOUND OF SILENCE MEANS…!!!!

    TO ME!? THISSSSS I BRING FWD AND SPEAK HERE IS WHAT!!!! THE SOUND OF SILENCE MEANS!!!

    But then hey!? I’m just the Old Disabled Lady who lives silently alone in this sea of hate and evil etc I have spoke of here!! I am just the person who is mistreated and abused since she was born by this kind!! And even now!! IIII AM JUST THE ONE WHO SAW GEORGE WENT THERE TRIED TO HELP!! Just the one who saw the dog in front of me dying from neglect and abuse and fought with them to rescue her and who managed to get her and then drive 2 hrs to take her to a safe place to be saved! While a whole GD park of onlookers and knowers did absolutely NOTHING!!!

    I am just the one who came home from the store night B4 last and opened my door to domestic abuse of the couple beside me! They were fighting badly!! He was hurting her!!! She was screaming bloody murder!!!! The baby was screaming bloody murder!!! I heard saw…. Hell the whole GD park could hear!!! BUT I WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO CALLED THE LAW SHAKING TO DEATH TERRIFIED I WOULD SEE AND HEAR THE BEATING THE MURDER OF A WOMAN AND A BABY BARELY A YR OLD!!! A BEAUTIFUL LITTLE BABY GIRL!!!

    EVERYWHERE I HAVE LIVED MY ENTIRE 58 YRS HAS BEEN LIKE THIS!!! WITH FOLKS HEARING SEEING KNOWING BUT REFUSING TO DO RT!!! REFUSING TO GET INVOLVED!! TO HELP!? TO CALL THE COPS! WHO USUALLY DO ABSOLUTELY NOTHING WHEN U DO!!!

    FOR 58 YRS I HAVE SEEN HEARD KNOWN…. HAVE BEEN A CONSTANT VICTIM OF ABUSE GREED SICKNESS OF THIS KIND! I SEE THE FULL DEEP TRUTH!!! THE REAL ISSUES!!!! ALLL THAT IS WRONG WITH SOCIETY!!!

    THE EVILS…. ETC… WE DID TO THE INDIANS WHAT HITLER DID TO THE JEWS!!! AND LOOK AT THE VIET NAM WAR…. ALLLL OF IT!!! COVID!!! AND WHAT WE SAW KNOW AND SEE WITH COPS HARRASSING AND BEATING AND MURDERING ANYONE OF COLOR! DISABLED FOLKS!!! ELDERLY!!! COPS R SUPPOSED TO BE RT GOOD! BUT MANY IF NOT MOST R NOT!! THEY R WHAT THEY R SUPPOSED TO PROTECT US FROM! THE RIOTS!!! THE FAKE SSNN PATRIOTS!! TRUMP!!! THE HATE AND PREDJUDICED HE PREACHES! THE VIOLENCE HE INSITED WHILE HE FN HID LIKE A GD COWARD!!!

    This couple… He B4 the other night beat her with a ball bat while she held their baby! Then tried to kill her with her car while she held his her baby! She had an order against him but yet went back! Blind stupid no intent to see to know to change!! This time he told her when she told him she would leave him again… That HELL NO SHE WONT!!! THAT SHE WILL NEVER EVER DO THAT AGAIN!!! BECAUSE HE WILL NEVER ALLOW IT!!! NEVER AGAIN!!! HE IS GOING TO KILL HER!!! AND THIER BABY IS IN THE MIDDLE OF THIS SUFFERING AND BEING ABUSED AND ALMOST KILLED!!! THIS BABY IS GOING TO DIE IF DHS DONT TAKE IT BACK AND KEEP IT!!! SHE IS GOING TO BE MURDERED!! BOTH!!! RT HERE!!! AND I AM GOING TO HEAR IT ALL!!!!

    AND THIS COULD BE PREVENTED IF OTHERS CARED OR DID THEIR JOBS!!! IF AUTHORIZES DIDNT BLOW GOOD FOLKS LIKE ME OFF WHO DO CARE!!! WHO DO TRY!!! THEY NEVER EVER LISTEN!!!! THEY NEVER DO ANYTHING!!!! THEN THWIR MURDERED!!! THEY DIE!!!

    THEN FOLKS SAY HOW SAD!? OR WTH HAPPENED HERE!? BUT NOTHING EVER CHANGES!!!!

    SORRY!!! I KNOW THIS IS LONG AND TURNED INTO A BOOK!!! BUT I HAVE JUST BEEN SOOOGD FED UP!!! SO FRUSTRATED!!!! SOOO GD ANGRY!!!! SOOO GD U LISTENED TO!!!!! SOOO UNHEARD! SOOO ALONE IN ALL THIA TRUTH AND KNOWLEDGE AND INSIGHT!!!!

    EVEN NOW! I AM ALONE IN ALL THIS I SPEAK OF HERE!! AND NO! IM NOT CRAZY!!! JUST ENSIGHTFUL!! JUST HONEST!! JUST REAL!!! I do suffer from PTSD! AND CPTSD!! TRUST ME! I SPEAK PURE TRUTH AND KNOWLEDGE HERE!! FOR I HAVE LIVED THIS SEEN THIS KNOWN THIS FOR 58 YRS!!!! AND NOTHING HAS CHANGED!!!!

    SOCIETY HAS JUST BECOME MORE SILENT!!!!! MORE BLIND!!! MORE IGNORANT!! MORE WRAPPED UP IN TECH SHIT AND IN SELFISHNESS AND GREED!!! POWER!!! FAME!!!! NOTHING TODAY IS REAL!!?? FEELINGS R EITHER BURIED DEEP OR NONEXISTENT!!! ROBOTS WITH NO FEELINGS NO NOTHING…

    I CANNOT BE SILENT ABOUT THIS ALONE ANY LONGER!!!! FOR THE SOUND OF SILENCE IS DEAFENING!!!! IT IS DEPRESSING! IT MAKES ME FAR TOO ANGRY AND FRUSTRATED!!! IT HAS EATEN AT MY SOUL FAR FAR FAR TOO LONG!!!

    EACH MIN OF EACH DAY I SEE THIS HEAR THIS KNOW THIS GO THRU THIS ALONE…!!! WITH NO ONE LISTENING!! NO ONE CARING!! NO ONE WANTING TO!! SEEING NONSTOP VIOLENCE AND CRUELTY AND DEATH!!! WHILE IT IS MADE TOTALLY NORMAL!! TOTALLY THE WAY THINGS R!!!

    HATED FOR CARING!!! HAT3D FOR SPEAKING UP!!! FOR HELPING!! ATTACKED REPEATEDLY FOR THIS! I AND MY SOUL R DYING!!!! AND THERE SEEMS TO BE NOT ONE GDMF THING THAT I CAN DO TO STOP ANYYYY OF THIS!!!

    🤔🤔🤔🤷🤷🤷🤧🤧🤧🥴😫🤯😬😳😣😰😕☹️😟🧐🤨😶🙄🙄🥺😩😲🤬🤬🤬🤫🙄🥺😟😥😥😥😢😢☹️🙁😕🤐🤐🤐😰😨😧😦😮😯😲😵😵😵🤮🤧🤧🤧🤧

    Liked by 1 person

      1. You’re most welcome and also thanks a lot for writting so beautifuly and transmitting so sentimental and cerebral messages of human communication in between the today lonely people! My best regards and stay well! 🙂 🙂 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  3. I have long taken the position that Paul Simon is not just a songwriter but a poet–one of America’s best, I think. I like his work so much that in the literature class I teach at the local college, we spend a week reading and analyzing the words of one of his songs. “The Sound of Silence” is one of the songs we dissect. The students seem to think (and I agree with them) that the last two lines is part of the theme in that last stanza. That people pray to false and empty neon gods they have created when the truth of life is found in simpler places, tied to daily living, regular people, people who are struggling. The interesting thing I find about Simon is that he was not considered one of the protest writers of the 1960s like Bob Dylan.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment